Web Posted: 12/07/2006 11:06 PM CST
Jennifer Hiller
Express-News Business Writer
The party isn’t exactly over for San Antonio real estate, but the champagne has stopped flowing.
Home builders, feeding off of the anxiety of the national real estate meltdown coupled with the typical seasonal slowdown, have started offering deals and incentives not available a few months ago.KB Home even has started to lay off employees.
The flurry of year-end deals can be attributed, in part, to an annual strategy builders use to move homes off the books for tax purposes. But there’s also a sense that 2007 won’t be as good as 2006, and that the frenzy that typified home building and sales in recent years has eased.
“I’m hearing more people being concerned than I am (hearing them be) ecstatic,” said Michael Moore, vice president of the Greater San Antonio Builders Association.
KB Home, one of San Antonio’s largest builders, laid off numerous employees Thursday.
The layoffs came just after KB Home exceeded its sales goals for its fiscal year ending in November.
Spokeswoman Cathy Teague said the company had to streamline the business to match the volume of work it expects next year, while still remaining profitable.
“We will continue to open new communities and expand in the market by offering new home designs and neighborhoods to attract new home buyers,” she said.
KB Home has laid off workers in other cities — recently in Denver and Las Vegas — but Teague said Thursday’s layoffs were a local decision and weren’t done as a directive from the corporate office. She wouldn’t confirm the number of employees who lost jobs.
Those layoffs likely will feed a growing sense of industry unease.
It’s a new feeling for San Antonio, where for the last year the city’s real estate market has been a shining contradiction to the rest of the country’s woes.
The new home market party started when Fortune magazine anointed San Antonio the nation’s strongest housing market, predicting an 8.3 percent home price appreciation in 2006, luring investors who helped push the market to record levels.
As a result, one segment of the real estate market already has a hangover: single-family home rentals.
Out-of-town investors flooding into San Antonio this year have glutted the market with rental homes, and the average rent has dropped $202 a month since this time last year, from $1,301 to $1,099, according to the San Antonio Board of Realtors.
At the end of October, renters had their pick of more than 2,000 homes. So far this year, more than 10,650 homes have gone onto the rental market — 22 percent more homes than last year.
Kevin Knight with Liberty Management Inc. said the out-of-state investors had a different mentality than local landlords, who traditionally bought fixer-uppers.
The out-of-state investors wanted new homes that required little maintenance.
“San Antonio investors used to buy for positive cash flow,” Knight said. “In California, they buy for appreciation. They’ll buy a house here and lose $200 to $300 a month and they don’t care.”
That’s helped contribute to a drop in rents.
“We’ve had owners who are used to getting $1,100 a month in rent and we tell them they have to drop their price,” Knight said. “They don’t want to hear that.”
One such owner is Missy Stagers, a real estate agent with Coldwell Banker D’Ann Harper Realtors. She owns five rental homes that used to be moneymakers, but now are breaking even.
“They’ve ruined our rental market,” Stagers said of the investors, many of whom cashed out of the East or West Coast markets and planted their money here. “You can now rent homes cheaper than you can buy.”
Real estate malaise has struck much of the country, but Texas, which never saw a rapid run up in prices, stayed largely immune.
San Antonio homes appreciated in value about 8 percent this year, and the state is projected to have stronger job growth than the rest of the country in 2007 — a critical factor in whether people buy homes.
A recent report from the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas said builders across the state have pulled back on starting homes and have increased incentives to sell rising inventory.
“On the new home side, we’re starting more houses than we’re selling,” said Bob Gardner of Gardner Financial Services.
Actual inventory figures were not immediately available, but new statistics should be released in January.
Business for home builders usually drops between September and January, often as much as 20 to 30 percent from spring and summer highs, but this seems to be larger trend than just a seasonal slowdown.
Centex Homes recently offered as much as $25,000 in incentives on its homes. Buyers could apply the money toward the down payment and closing costs or add upgrades to the home.
Such deals were unheard of a few months ago.
“We hit a wall at Halloween,” said Leslie Mullins, operational marketing manager for Centex Homes in San Antonio. “It’s not just us. We’ve spoken to all of the other big builders in town.”
Home buyers should expect to see aggressive marketing and the ability to negotiate prices on new home, said Jim Gaines, research economist with the Real Estate Center at Texas A&M University.
“The builders are seeing the market slow down. It’s doesn’t mean it’s falling off a cliff,” Gaines said.
Despite the troubles, no one predicts a San Antonio market crash.
Low interest rates for mortgages and job growth should drive sales and construction, even if it’s not at a party-atmosphere pace.
And the market for existing homes remains strong. It takes less time to sell a home this year than last — 60 days on average, compared with 70.
No one can say when the party might be over, but as Travis Kessler, CEO of the San Antonio Board of Realtors, puts it: “At some point you can’t go up forever.”